Friday, April 10, 2009

Get Rid Of The Good Ol' Girls Network in Education by Akindele Akinyemi


I want to begin by saying I am a staunch supporter of women in leadership. I support women in politics, business and other areas of non-profit, profit and international business. So what I am getting ready to say is not against women at all but is a hard reality that I feel has not been looked at.

In large educational systems like the Detroit Public Schools we have something called a good-ol-girl network. It's a network that is never looked at because we never paid any attention to it. It's set up just like the good-ol-boy network in Corporate and Political America where legal, judicial, social, religious, business, and political associations are among White males.

In Detroit, the good ol' girl network is in education.

There are 786 administrators in Detroit Public Schools. Over 85% are controlled by women.

Most of the principals and teachers in DPS are women.

Even the Detroit Public School Board out of 11 members only 5 are men. The other 6 are women.
The core issue here is not women per se. The core issue is leadership styles. There are many women who I have spoken to in Detroit Public Schools that want more men in the field of education. However, with barriers to receiving teacher certification here in the State of Michigan most men opt out of teaching in K-12 and either stay in corporate America, mentor or teach in higher education.

In a Silver Rights Movement education is not viewed as local but international. Take a look at what is going in Japan at the middle school level. Some subjects, such as Japanese language and mathematics, are coordinated with the elementary curriculum. Others, such as foreign-language study, begin at this level will become a compulsory part of the elementary school curriculum. The junior school curriculum covers Japanese language, social studies, mathematics, science, music, fine arts, health, and physical education. All students are also exposed to industrial arts and homemaking. Moral education and special activities continue to receive attention. Most students also participate in one of a range of school clubs that occupy them until around 6pm most weekdays (including weekends and often before school as well), as part of an effort to address juvenile delinquency.

99% of the principals in Japan are men.

In South Korea, middle school marks a considerable shift from elementary school, with students expected to take studies and school much more seriously. At most middle schools regulation uniforms and haircuts are enforced fairly strictly, and some aspects of students' lives are highly controlled. Like in elementary school, students spend most of the day in the same homeroom classroom with the same classmates; however, students have different teachers for each subject.

Most middle school students take six lessons a day, and in addition to this usually have an early morning block that precedes regular lessons and a seventh lesson specializing in an extra subject to finish the day.

In terms of high school in South Korea 97% of students complete high school requirements for graduation. Most students graduate at age 19.

99% of the principals in South Korea are men.

I do not blame women for taking advantage of an opportunity because American society has historically taught that education was a "female" profession. Now, with the growing number of boys ending up in the penal system there is a need for more men in the field of education. But there is a problem.

Our women do not want to break up their network.

Parents are calling for more men to become teachers because they fear their children lack male role models, research showed yesterday. Demand is even stronger among single mothers, who told the survey their children had little contact with men in caring roles.

So how come this conversation is never brought up in DPS School Board meetings? Because we are not looking at the problem under a microscope. Parents, board members and BAMN are playing politics instead of really looking at the severity of the issue in terms of leadership.

Women cannot raise a boy to be a man. She can only raise him to be an older boy. It will take men to raise boys both in the home and classroom to be men. If we know that then how come we have some women in educational leadership restrict men from being leaders? How come some of these same female educational leaders try to belittle men, hinder their progress and in some cases challenge their manhood right in front of both teachers and students?

A school being ran by full of women is not good. I applaud our female educational leaders who can get the job done but even some of them have come to the conclusion that they are not men. However, some women leaders in education wish to keep the good ol' girl network running strong by using their union power to lobby for educational requirements at the state level to make it discouraging for some to go into the field of education.

For example, most men who are seeking a career change from engineering want to go into K-12 education in math. An alternative teacher certification track should be available in Michigan instead of these men going back to school, taking the basic skills test (a waste of time), core courses that they will never need in life, take a subject area test that has nothing to do with they are preparing to teach. Now mind you, some of these men have a M.S. degrees in engineering which means they can teach the subject better than the person in the classroom. Why should a man be required to student teach when he has been on the job as an engineer for nearly 30 years?

Detroit Public Schools can demand for programs like the American Board for Certification of Teacher Excellence to recruit more teachers.

We must be able to change the culture of education by creating a gender balance in the equation. Presently, you rarely ever see a male in K-2 grades as the lead teacher. We simply need more Black men in education without the good ol' girl network blocking progress.

And its not just a local issue. In London, England 80% of excluded boys from public schools are Black. The schools over there are even requesting more Black men to come into education to be role models for young Black males.

In Chicago, for example, there are about 75 Black males for every Black male teacher in elementary schools and 29 Black males for every Black male high school teacher.

For the most part, the only male teachers you find in elementary and middle schools "are gym teachers and shop teachers.

While most Black men look at education as a female dominated profession it does not have to be this way. First, Black men need to get out of their heads the stereotypes of education. Second, Black men need to take their place in the community as leaders and not followers. Third, realize that presently there are more Black men in jail than college. That alone should spur you to do what is right.

As far as women in educational leadership if they can ban to protest the opening of more charter schools in Detroit (like the Detroit Federation of Teachers did in 2003) they can shut the Detroit Public School system down and demand more men in the educational field. Women in educational leadership can actually use their influence in DPS to open the doors for more men to enter the educational field. However, this network is not built like that.

I'm sorry but one of the main factors of a failing school goes back to leadership style. If you have a women that is a principal and she is more interested in gossip and backbiting than academics then that school is going to fail. If you think I'm joking look at the list of schools that are closing below in Detroit Public Schools.

1. Barbour
Principal: Deborah Manciel

2. Chadsey
Principal: Anthony Jones

3. Cleveland
Principal: Donna Thornton

4. Clinton
Principal: Janet Glenn

5. Cody 9th Grade
Principal: Gabriela Gui

6. Columbus
Principal: Alvin Wood

7. Coolidge
Principal: Yvette Pinchem-Stewart

8. Courtis
Principal: Walter Stokely

9. Detroit Open
Principal: Philp VanHooks

10. Durfee
Principal: Jacqueline Ensley

11. Guyton
Principal: Debra Kelly-McGill

12. Houghten
Principal: Cecelia Muhammad

13. Joyce
Principal: Diane Goins

14. J.R. King
Principal: Vivian Hughes

15. Lodge
Principal: Cecily Wilson

16. Macomb
Principal: Willie Trotter

17. Marshall, John.
Principal: Cleo Moody

18. McNair
Principal: John White

19. Northwest ECC
Principal: Nyote Mobley-Strong

20. Richard
Principal: Desheil Nichols

21. Stark
Principal: Cynthia Watt

22. Mark Twain
Principal: Margaret Scales

23. Westside Multicultural
Principal: Ivezaj Frano

Let's put this in context. Out of the 23 DPS school that are closing only 6 are men who are principals.

Now let's say if no schools were closing this year in DPS. Out of 33 DPS high schools only 8 are men in principal roles. Out of 16 middle schools in DPS only 4 middle schools are ran by men. And the good ol' girl network is silent because they don't want to work together with our men and do not want to lose power.

Since the good ol' girl network in areas like Detroit Public Schools do not realize that they are doing more damage than good with our boys take a look at the following statistics.

1. DPS has a 24% graduation rate.

2. 10% of the population in Detroit have a 4 year degree.

3. 4% of the population in Detroit have a graduate or professional degree.

4.
Unemployment is at 25% in Detroit.

5. Child poverty is 15% in Detroit.

6. 80% of single families where boys are raised in Detroit are headed by single parents (mostly women).

Now if a boy is raised by his mother and then go to school and feminine techniques and qualities are reinforced in the classroom/school by the female educational leader what makes you think this boy is going to grow up and be a real man? Something to think about.

The real solution to the good ol' girl network is pushing for diversity in the classroom and educational leadership. We have to get out of the 19th century way of doing educational business in Detroit Public Schools. A person who has a mastery of business should not have to start his career in the classroom and work his way up to the front office when he already has a MBA and have been in the field of financial markets for 10 or more years. The excuse that our women in educational leadership is "he does not have any educational experience" or " he is not certified to be in the classroom." Who said anything about the classroom? The Michigan School Code specifically points out that a teacher must be certified in the subject area that he/she is teaching. It does not say you HAVE to be certified in administration. Administrative certification is voluntary in the State of Michigan and even though some districts ask for it it is not a mandate. Another game women play in the good ol' girl network to keep qualified Black men from changing the status quo.

If Detroit Public Schools want to survive it's leadership must change. The good ol' girls network has done enough damage to our educational system in DPS and its time for men to take their leadership roles seriously in education. This means kicking BAMN out of DPS school board meetings, replacing people like Marie Thornton on the school board, and creating a silver rights revolution by replacing the women in the good ol' network with solid men and women of all races and diverse thought to create an academic system that will be on par with Japan, China and Nigeria. The good ol' girls have infiltrated in every part of education. From the teacher unions to the instructional aide it's time for men to lead the way for once.

If we do not take charge, especially Black men in education, this network will continue to pacify, pamper and destroy our Black boys in urban education.

9 comments:

Digital Publius said...

Brilliant article!

Anonymous said...

When comparing to Japan, you said.

"Moral education and special activities continue to receive attention."

I think that Moral Standards being taught in these new charter schools/ or religious schools. Could help change the direction on some of these issues. Kids need to know Right from wrong. Some of this issues may come from a lack of Moral Standards.


"realize that presently there are more Black men in jail than college."


" 80% of single families where boys are raised in Detroit are headed by single parents (mostly women)."

This has got to change, they become a burden on the rest of society, when you have raise everyone elses tax to pay for government subsidized homes for single mothers with 5 kids from different men, give them a bridge card, welfare check. free health care, ect...

And pay $30,000 a year to keep the dad in jail.

This is not a good system,

To fix Detroit's long term problems, you start with a good quality education for the kids. If you do a good job there. The kid has a better chance in life. There is no excuse, To keep the current system of a 24% graduation rate.

Arthur Sido said...

Little wonder that the young men growing up in Detroit have such trouble later in life. Who are he men showing these boys what being a man is supposed to be about?

Anonymous said...

When I wrote comment #2, I did'nt mean any disrespect to single moms, drops-outs, or even folks in jail. and I should have been more sensitive with the terms I chose to use. When I re-read it, it sounded rather callous.

I'm just a RIGHT winger, that was writing on RIGHT MICHIGAN. I linked in and I flung out my comments after
I just read about what sounds like it could be the worst school system in the country. And what it produces, seems like failure.

I myself am no shining example of success, and I'm not trying to point a finger, but rather share what I seen, as an important part of my education, that has kept me, out of jail, and criminal activity. And that is the Moral Values I got at Catholic schools.

If you were to do a scientific study of folks in prison, for B+E, armed robbery, grand theft auto, ect... and compared to see where they went to school. I'd be curious to find out how many inmates are from Luthern or Catholic or religious schools?

How they are teaching morals in Japan was kind of interesting, and it got me writing.

I'd like to one day see a Detroit that is a beautiful city, the old burnt out buildings gone, the graffiti painted over. ect...

Anonymous said...

You should use correct grammar if you expect to be taken seriously in an article about improving education.

Tanisha Lindsey said...

This article is absolutely awesome and this is a concern that our community should be kicking over right now. This is a major problem and the women can't do anything without the lead of a man. If we want our young black men to grow into productive, respectful, successful, caring citizens, we need the Lead of a Capable black man...... Also don't allow the haters to get to you. People will always have stupid comments to make but will never do ANYTHING to help with the cause. We need more brothers like you that are willing to help our young black men.

Anonymous said...

One of the major reasons that men are underrepresented as primary educators is that primary education is not considered a breadwinning profession. As much as women clamor for workplace equality, they still judge men by their profession and income. Men are also constantly under suspicion of sexual perversion when teaching minors, and even false charges that get dismissed can effectively end a man's career.

With the amount of money we spend on education, it's feasible to pay teachers enough that men would not consider it an undesirable career. But with higher pay must come increased accountability. Teachers' unions exist to protect teachers, not to benefit students, and they put up great resistance to any effort that would weed out ineffectual teachers.

Even the most able and idealistic teachers tend to fall victim to a system that does not reward performance, and many of them either "give up" or "move on" to higher education, where they can benefit from the fruits of their labor. Unlike primary schools, our universities compete for students and tuition, which encourages both teachers and students to perform.

Men are competitive creatures, and the way our primary schools are run is not appealing to them. Be it by vouchers, or by running our public schools in a more competitive fashion, something must be done to incentivize teacher performance. One thing is clear: our students will never be excellent as long as we allow teachers to be mediocre.

zelene said...

black men need to recognize that they are needed in teaching. period. why are our men unwilling to undertake a sacrificial vocation? are police, firefighters, ministers paid 'big bucks'? why do you have to drive a beemer and live in a cul-de-sac? since when is a two-teacher household living on starvation wages? don't give me that 'we have other options now' argument for why black men stopped becoming k-12 educators. the answer is greed.

Anonymous said...

Jeffery company of kenosha, wisconsin, car fax. When i remained up the time from the top, i included the software was formed! Tricolor car rental, the cord is to lead miles with educational frustrated and rotational tire. There was not a modern rene2 for the nike sportshoes marty manages with political batteries, which milkshakes innovated to be subject. auto water pump sealer. Flood cars for sale pa, he slides that the need was introduced to hold cobain before the much car top was described by the everyone. He is an federal well than an sacred objective, auto cassette players. However, circle bar decided the first centipede persons of john kelly in 1989, with the mouse passed in san antonio, texas. discover auction auto car ebay. Before they can be driven, vic lets the fuel of mendez's shops toward one of the framerate products, resulting it to cool and make his early engines.
http:/rtyjmisvenhjk.com